• Home
  • Contact Us!
  • Privacy Policy

Radio Metta

  • Home
  • Business
  • Education
  • Health
  • Home Deco
  • News
  • Real Estate
  • Technology
  • Contact Us!
  • Privacy Policy
Home» Real Estate»Service tax on purchase of specific under construction flats: pay or not to pay?

Service tax on purchase of specific under construction flats: pay or not to pay?

Saheli 09 Jul 2016 Real Estate Comments Off on Service tax on purchase of specific under construction flats: pay or not to pay? 17 Views

The author argues whether service tax on purchase of flats from builders in under construction housing projects should be paid or not.

In the wake of rising cost burden of home buyers, comes a ray of hope in the form of a recent decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of Suresh Kumar Bansal Vs Union of India & Others 2016-VIL-284-DEL-ST. The High Court held that in a scenario where the price of under construction flats includes the cost of land, no service tax shall be payable.

Summary of High Court’s decision
High Court held that the service tax is only payable on the value of services and not on the value of land. The mechanism for ascertaining the value of services (by excluding the value of land) involved in such contracts should have been provided either under the Finance Act, 1994, or the Rules issued under the said Act. In absence of any mechanism within the Act or the Rules to exclude the value of land, no service tax can be imposed on consideration of under construction flats wherein the value of land is included in such consideration. The High Court further further held that even though an abatement of 75% is given by a notification, it cannot substitute the lack of statutory machinery provisions in the Act or Rules framed in this regard. Considering the above, petitioner was allowed refund of tax already paid along with an interest of 6% from the date of deposit till the date of refund. The above judgment of the High Court pertains to a period before July 2012.

Applicability of the above judgment under the current law
From July 2012, a radical change was introduced in service tax wherein all services except certain services specified in the Negative List, were subjected to service tax. However, even from July 2012 and till date, the Act and Rules pertaining to service tax do not contain any provision for exclusion of value of land. An abatement is provided vide a Notification and, therefore, the legal situation from July 2012 till date is exactly same as was there in the above judgment. Thus, by drawing analogy from the above judgment, from July 2012 onwards, no service tax was payable on the under construction flats where the consideration for such flats included the value of land.

Possibility of refund of service tax already paid?
Petitioner has been allowed refund by High Court along with interest at 6% p.a. Other home buyers may also apply to the tax authorities for refund of the service tax paid by them on purchase of under construction flats.

Home buyers would not get the refund of service tax from the builders, as the service tax collected by them must have already been deposited with the service tax authorities. Accordingly, approaching the builder for refund for service tax may not work.

Future Outlook
Anticipating an appeal by the Central Government to Supreme Court, builders are likely to continue charging service tax from buyers because in case the Supreme Court rules in favour of the revenue then the builders would be required to pay service tax along with interest. In a scenario where such tax has not been collected by them, the same would be a cost to them along with interest.

One possible solution, which might be acceptable to both the builders and home buyers, is opening an escrow account wherein buyers can deposit service tax amount subject to the condition that if the High Court’s decision is overruled by the Supreme Court, the builders can use the amount for payment of service tax. However, the interest liability would always be an issue in this case. If the High Court’s judgment is upheld by the Supreme Court, then the amount will be refunded back to the customer from escrow account.

Till the time the Supreme Court decides the said issue, ambiguity regards levy of service tax on such contracts will exist despite Delhi High Court’s decision. Taking note of the observations of High Court, Central Government may make suitable amendments in the service tax law so as to insert a proper mechanism for ascertaining the value of service portion in such contracts.

Thus, inspite of favourable judgment of the High Court, possibility of relief to be extended to the home buyers looks challenging.

[Source:- The Economic Time]

construction flats: not of on or pay purchase service specific Tax to under 2016-07-09
Tags construction flats: not of on or pay purchase service specific Tax to under
Facebook Twitter Stumble linkedin Pinterest More

Authors

Posted by : Saheli
Previous Article :

DJI’s latest update allows verified drone users to bypass its No-Fly technology

Next Article :

Blue Marble to Showcase the Latest Innovations in Blue Marble Technology at the ISPRS Congress

Related Articles

Our Ultimate List Of 135 Real Estate Blog Topic Ideas

Loknath Das 27 Dec 2021

Budget 2021: The Real Estate Expectation

Loknath Das 18 Dec 2021

QUESTIONS TO ASK AT AN OPEN HOUSE

Loknath Das 14 Dec 2021

Latest Post

News

Your SEO Budget Is Determining Your Success

admin 03 Sep 2022
News

WAN Connection Method – Frame Relay

admin 26 Aug 2022
Education

GESS Proudly Supports and Sponsors UAE Based Team in Global STEM Challenge

Loknath Das 28 Jul 2022
Technology

The Samsung Galaxy Z Flip4 gets FCC certification

Loknath Das 22 Jul 2022
Education

USF faculty, students to present at 2022 American Educational Research Association Annual Meeting

Loknath Das 22 Jul 2022
Technology

“Critical” We Understand Digital Money’s Impact: US Policymaker

Loknath Das 07 Jun 2022
Health

Firefly Health Taps Oshi Health to Add Whole-Person Digestive Care to Its Virtual Specialty Network

Loknath Das 06 Jun 2022
September 2023
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  
« Sep    
  • Home
  • Contact Us!
  • Privacy Policy
Copyright 2016, All Rights Reserved
Magazine Blog News WordPress Theme